Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Diks Ancveirs's avatar

**When State Secrecy Becomes a Shield Against Accountability**

The doctrine of “neither confirm nor deny” raises a fundamental question: at what point does the protection of legitimate state interests become the protection of institutions from accountability?

National security and confidentiality may justify certain restrictions on disclosure. But secrecy must never become an automatic substitute for legal reasoning, independent scrutiny or effective remedies.

This problem extends beyond intelligence services and historical conflicts.

In my independent legal research concerning judicial proceedings and property enforcement in Latvia, I examine a related concern: what happens when procedural decisions, delayed protection and institutional responses leave citizens without an effective remedy before irreversible consequences occur?

The situations are legally different, but the underlying question deserves examination:

**Who holds an institution accountable when its own procedures prevent meaningful scrutiny of its decisions?**

Article 13 of the European Convention on Human Rights and Article 47 of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights, where applicable, provide important legal foundations for examining effective remedies and judicial protection.

The rule of law cannot be measured solely by whether institutions follow procedures. It must also be measured by whether those procedures genuinely protect the rights they were created to serve.

I invite researchers, legal professionals and journalists examining institutional accountability to consider my related publication:

**When Institutions Fear Their Own Mistakes**

https://medium.com/@diks.ancveirs/when-institutions-fear-their-own-mistakes-bef76d6f34b3

**A democratic state should not fear the discovery of its mistakes. It should fear becoming incapable of correcting them.**

Because justice delayed until the consequences become irreversible risks becoming justice that exists only on paper.

Ready for more?